The best muffin tin is responsible for baking perfectly rounded, crisp-edged muffins. When preparing muffins, you want a tin pan that can bear oven’s high temperatures and provides several cups to bake muffins. However, there are some factors you shouldn’t overlook, such as nonstick properties and handling features. To help you pick the right one for your baking needs, read through our in-depth review of the seven best muffin tins. This review will guide you in deciding which one suits your budget and requirements.
Comparison Chart
| IMAGE | PRODUCT | DETAILS | PRICE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wilton Premium Nonstick Bakeware Muffin and Cupcake Pan | The Wilton muffin and cupcake pan comes with a nonstick steel surface that allows you to bake goods without worrying about overcooked muffins. | ||
| Nordic Ware 12 Cup Aluminum Muffin Pan | The Nordic bakeware comes with a heavy-duty aluminum 12 cup muffin pan that emphasizes its nonstick surface. | ||
| Rachael Ray Nonstick Bakeware 12-Cup Muffin Tin | Excellent build quality, nonstick surface, and ergonomics, Rachel Ray is the best muffin tin offered at an affordable price. | ||
| Keliwa 12 Cup Silicone Muffin Cupcake Baking Pan | The Keliwa 12-cup silicone muffin pan provides a nonstick solution to your baking problems. | ||
| USA Pan Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin Pan | The 12 cup USA Pan Bakeware features an Americoat layer that allows quick release of baked goods easily. | ||
| Wilton 12-Cup Nonstick Muffin Pan | This 12-cup Wilton muffin pan also offers much value than its rivals, as you can buy it at a very low price. | ||
| Oxo Good Grips 12 Cup Muffin Pan | The Oxo Good Grips nonstick muffin pan boasts delicious baking and quick release baked goods to its rivals. |
A Detailed Review on the 7 Best Muffin Tins
Wilton Premium Nonstick Bakeware Muffin and Cupcake Pan
The Wilton muffin and cupcake pan comes with a nonstick steel surface that allows you to bake goods without worrying about overcooked muffins.
Product Highlights
Wilton nonstick bakeware comes with oversized handles that improve grip for easy handling. Even if it’s loaded, you will not have a hard time moving the pan to and from the oven. The pan is dishwasher safe, but it is recommended to hand wash it with warm, soapy water to prolong its lifespan and quality. This product comes with a limited 10-year warranty, which assures your pan’s longevity.
The Good
This muffin pan can bake 12 cups and is made of food-grade steel. It also has even heat distribution making sure your muffin doesn’t get burned at the bottom. The pan’s nonstick surface permits easy food release and cleaning.
The Bad
One major drawback of this pan is it lacks holes on the side, which is necessary if you hang the pan for storage.
PROs
- Maximum grip
- Dishwasher safe
- Even heat distribution
- Nonstick surface
- Easy to clean
CONs
- Does not come with holes on the sides
- May not be rust resistant
- Durability is an issue
Nordic Ware 12 Cup Aluminum Muffin Pan
The Nordic bakeware comes with a heavy-duty aluminum 12 cup muffin pan that emphasizes its nonstick surface.
Product Highlights
The food-grade pan is made of aluminum and guarantees a rust-free surface, and lasts for a lifetime. The excellent heat conductivity of the pan also guarantees baking the muffins inside and outside. The Nordic Ware is a 100% food-safe muffin pan. This pan makes a delicious muffin or cupcake without burning the bottom due to its natural nonstick property and gives the pan’s superior longevity. This best muffin pan remains the same for a lifetime, rustproof and warp-resistant.
The Good
This 12 muffin pan delivers heat rapidly and evenly to obtain the best baking performance. No hot spots, so even when you’re undercooking goods, you won’t be smoking any muffins. Excellent design and comes with nonstick properties allowing this pan to be cleaned easily. It also helps the foods to be released quickly.
The Bad
Nordic bakeware could be the best muffin tin on this list if not for two important drawbacks. First is the lack of a nonstick layer on the surface that allows the muffin to get burned, and second is it’s not dishwasher safe. You need to wash this pan by hand only.
PROs
- Food safe and rustproof
- Chemical-free layer
- Warp resistant
- Even heat distribution
CONs
- The pan is not dishwasher safe
- Lack of nonstick properties
- Durability is a concern
Rachael Ray Nonstick Bakeware 12-Cup Muffin Tin
Excellent build quality, nonstick surface, and ergonomics, Rachel Ray is the best muffin tin offered at an affordable price.
Product Highlights
Snug-fitting silicone handles with heat tolerance of up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit are excellent features of Rachel Ray muffin pan. These user-friendly extra-wide handles provide the right space for gripping the pan without using oversized potholders. After a good muffin baking, you will have a safe and easy time moving the pan’s hot surface with its heat resistant colored rubber grip. For optimum longevity and toughness, the pan is heavy-duty food-safe steel.
The Good
This best muffin pan is designed with sturdy steel construction that will stand the test of time and even provides you quality baking. The Rachael Ray’s inside and outside layers are nonstick; this makes it easy to clean. The interior also makes the muffin easy to release. Washing the pan should be no problem as it is graded dishwasher safe by Rachel Ray.
The Bad
What we don’t like about this muffin pan is it’s not safe for microwaves and freezers. The pan tends to warp and bend, making this one unusable.
PROs
- Comes with heat resistant silicone handle
- Nonstick interior surface
- Easy to clean
- Durable
CONs
- Unsafe for freezer and microwave
- The nonstick feature loses its effect after a few uses
- The pan tends to warp or bend
Keliwa 12 Cup Silicone Muffin Cupcake Baking Pan
The Keliwa 12-cup silicone muffin pan provides a nonstick solution to your baking problems.
Product Highlights
This FDA approved Keliwa pan is made of food-grade nonstick silicone surface. This means the best muffin tin is safe for baking food. It is also safe to place inside the freezer and microwave, making this pan an outstanding piece compared to its rivals. Another highlight of Keliwa pan is it can withstand 450 degrees Fahrenheit temperature. You can rely on this pan to last a lifetime. You can also bake cupcakes or muffins with this one without using a wrapper as this pan releases baked goods easily.
The Good
The silicone material is also the one that makes the pan easiest to store. You should fold it for storage once you have washed it. It won’t be harmed by folding because the pan unfolds quickly into its original form. The best muffin pan here is a lightweight one. However, it is very durable and does not crack, fade, rust, or scrape. This lightweight characteristic makes it a cozy pan that anyone can use. Made from pure silicone grade food, it does not retain heat. However, it does heat up fairly quickly and uniformly distributes heat to give you pleasant pastries.
The Bad
Some users say this muffin pan is flexible for their preference, making it uncomfortable to hold with a load.
PROs
- Easy to use
- Scratch and rust-resistant
- Flexible and nonstick surface
- Even heat distribution
CONs
- The pan has no handles
- Uncomfortable to hold for some due to its flexibility
- May not be durable enough
USA Pan Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin Pan
The 12 cup USA Pan Bakeware features an Americoat layer that allows quick release of baked goods easily.
Product Highlights
USA muffin pan is made of aluminized heavy-gauge steel and 12 regular cups for baking cupcakes. It is backed with a lifetime warranty, making sure it will handle any baking goods. The Americoat nonstick coating ensures well-baked muffins come out quickly and in great condition. This chemical-free coating is silicone and BPA, PTFE, and PFOA free. It is also warp and rust-resistant, plus you can easily clean this one without nipping the outer layer.
The Good
This surface allows quick removal of muffins and easy cleaning afterward. Most users praise this product’s durability, and it is heavy gauge aluminum and steel. This design gives you heat distribution for cupcakes and muffins that is finely crafted. Their special fluted shape further advantages the muffins as it allows for improved airflow.
The Bad
Some users complain the baking pan sticks into the baked goods even after greasing the muffin cups before using it.
PROs
- Chemical-free surface
- Easy to clean
- Heavy-gauge aluminum design
- Even heat distribution
CONs
- Not dishwasher safe
- The surface tends to stick on the muffins
- You need cupcake papers/liners to bake good
Wilton 12-Cup Nonstick Muffin Pan
This 12-cup Wilton muffin pan also offers much value than its rivals, as you can buy it at a very low price.
Product Highlights
Wilton 12-cup nonstick muffin pan showcases an easy release steel surface. This feature helps you to take out baked goods, and you can clean the pan quickly. The pan also comes with wide edges so you can maximize gripping the pan when moving it from the oven. Since this product is dishwasher safe, you don’t have to think about washing off the pan from food particles left. Combined with the nonstick layer, cleaning this pan is effortless.
The Good
It is fortified with a nonstick coating that quickly releases your baked goods. Also, this feature makes cleaning easier and quicker. The pan is also covered with a 5-year limited warranty to minimize purchase danger or product failure. The handles are wide enough, and even with the mittens on, this product is safe to hold and easy to use. If you need to cover your cupcakes or muffins, this one comes with a plastic cover.
The Bad
Although this muffin pan is offered at an affordable price, its build and design are not safe to place inside the microwave or freezer.
PROs
- Nonstick coating
- Wide handles
- Fast and even heating
- Comes with plastic cover
CONs
- The pan tends to bend easily
- Not safe for microwave or freezer use
- Durability is an issue
OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Muffin Pan
The Oxo Good Grips nonstick muffin pan boasts delicious baking and quick release baked goods to its rivals.
Product Highlights
Made of aluminized steel, known for its superior distribution of heat and durability, this one is an excellent product to purchase. A dual-layer, ceramic-reinforced coating guarantees the quick release of food while keeping away the pan from rust, scratching, or staining. The pan’s solid grip is improved by its square-rolled sides, which also provide additional gripping strength. This feature makes it simple to move the pan to and from the oven.
The Good
The dual-layer coating allows users to easily release baked goods while making your pan scrape, stain, and corrosion-resistant. Such edges add baked quality and strength to the pan’s design. It has nonslip features making it simpler and smoother to use this best muffin tin. The pan’s microtextured design improves the airflow around the baking goods and makes it hassle-free to bake.
The Bad
What we don’t like about the best muffin tin from Oxo is it’s not dishwasher safe. You will need to clean the pan by hand wash only.
PROs
- Dual-layer nonstick coating
- Scratch and stain-resistant
- Heavy-gauge aluminized steel design
- Comes with nonslip handles
CONs
- Not dishwasher safe
- The product tends to warp under high heat
- Durability is an issue
Conclusion
A high-quality muffin pan is essential for baking mouthwatering muffins and even cupcakes. The important considerations you need to remember before purchasing muffin tins are covered in this product guide, so buying will be easier for you. With nonstick surfaces and better grip handles on your tin pans, you can never go wrong. Find out more about muffin pans.